• Menu
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Before Header

  • About Us
  • Lexicon
  • Contact Us
  • Our Store
  • ↑
  • ↓
  • ←
  • →

Balloon Juice

Come for the politics, stay for the snark.

Almost as fun as hiking the Appalachian Trail.

All your base are belong to Tunch.

What fresh hell is this?

Yes we did.

Dinky Hocker Shoots Smack!

The Math Demands It!

Just a few bad apples.

Verified, but limited!

This blog is Obama’s Katrina.

This is how realignments happen…

Gastritis Broke My Calculator

No one could have predicted…

Where tasty lettuce and good mustard aren’t elitist.

Wetsuit optional.

And we’re all out of bubblegum.

Peak wingnut was a lie.

Shallow, uninformed, and lacking identity.

Mission Accomplished!

Screw the Judean People’s Front. Splitters.

Shock troops for the Unitarian Jihad.

Hot Air and Ill Informed Banter

This blog will pay for itself.

Too inconsequential to be sued

Technically true, but collectively nonsense.

Mobile Menu

  • Politics
  • Open Threads
  • Topics
  • Authors
  • Pet Photos by 12/13
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Lexicon
  • Our Store
  • Politics
  • Open Threads
  • Pet Blogging
  • On The Road
  • Garden Chats
  • Pet Photos by 12/13
You are here: Home / Anderson On Health Insurance / Plumbing and the US Healthcare system

Plumbing and the US Healthcare system

by David Anderson|  July 30, 20197:48 am| 4 Comments

This post is in: Anderson On Health Insurance

Facebook0Tweet0Email0

Plumbing matters.  Complexity matters for project timelines and launch dates.

This is overwhelmingly true for health insurance, health finance and healthcare access.

We need to think about why there are transitions periods built into the various healthcare bills that are being proposed by all of the Democratic presidential candidates right now.  These bills vary in scope, complexity and how they interact with the current framework (ACA, Medicare, Medicaid and Employer Sponsored Insurance (ESI)).  That variance leads to very different plausible time frames.  Bills that tweak the current parameters of the ACA individual market by extending subsidies to 600% or 6,000% Federal Poverty Level (FPL) should have shorter minimum necessary lead times than bills that completely restructure eighteen percent of the US economy.

I poked at this type of question in the summer of 2017 when there was a plan-like rumor that one possibility for the GOP was to repeal the ACA with a 12/31/19 drop-dead date and create a crisis point.  At that crisis point, a big bipartisan bill would be signed that would have mostly conservative policy priorities in it but since it was bipartisan, no one would be responsible and no one could be blamed.  One of my points in that post was the seventeen month lead time in that proposal was grossly inadequate for a bill passed that afternoon.

Let’s work our way through the process of a major revamp first and then a minor revamp.  We will assume that your favorite bill (of any flavor) passes this afternoon, everyone has a hangover celebrating on July 31, so actual work starts on August 1, 2019.  I’m going to give a set of scenarios that are in the 95th percentile of GOOD NEWS.  

Major Revamp

Any major revision of the US Healthcare system will need significant rule making from federal agencies.  The federal agencies need to take what Congress has written and figure out how to actually make it work.  The ACA had several hundred instructions of the “Secretary Shall…” and those ranged from when open enrollment periods should be, to how calories were to be counted, and what the de minimas allowable actuarial variation in metal bands could be.  Rule making (at least rule making that will stand up in court) requires notice and comment.  Let’s be super-optimistic and say the major rules are drafted in six months.  This is fast as every interested stakeholder ranging from hospitals, doctor groups, pharmacies, consumer advocates, patient advocates, bed frame manufacturers and thousands of entities in between will want to be in the information sessions.  White papers will be produced faster than trade proposals on deadline day.

Once the draft rule is completed, it has to go through internal governmental review and then it goes out to the public for notice and comment for at least thirty days.  Here the public can comment on the proposal rule.  Some of those comments will be insightful, evidence based and useful, others will be rote repetitions of ideological direction.  The rule making entities has to read and respond to all the comments.  A good rule making process will use this as an opportunity to learn and adjust.  This learning process will take another four to six months to produce a final rule that is neither arbitrary nor capricious.

We’re at a year now.

Now industry (docs, hospitals, insurers, nursing homes, oxygen suppliers etc) has not been sitting around waiting.  They’ve been trying to anticipate what the rules could be given the black letter law and whatever initial guidance that is coming out of the government.  But they’re somewhat stuck until final rules are out to begin major changes to business systems, IT infrastructure and the finance and billing systems.  A major change like Medicare for All or dedicated Health Savings Accounts and high deductible plans for everyone requires massive back-end changes.  Industry scopes out the changes and figure that it is a twelve to eighteen month project.  The ACA plumbing job for insurers to get to initial operating capability was a 24-30 month plumbing job.  But I’m giving good news estimates right now.

So the nerds start programming and the consultants start consulting on change management. We are two years in.  At the same time, whoever came out of the bill signing ceremony as either a policy or ideological loser is in court.  Their case is working its way through the system and by now, it might be appealable to the Supreme Court.  The Supreme Court takes the case and issues a big ruling in the Spring of 2021 that either is a complete thumbs up for the law or a minor change at the furthest corner of the law.  Oh yeah, we just had an election, so there might be a major political curveball about to be thrown.

So now we’re 30-36 months in and the government and industry are about ready to go live.  Day 1, depending on how ambitious your favorite bill is, could see millions to tens of millions to hundreds of millions of people trying to figure out the new system.  It better be mechanically sound on Day 1, so the temptation to pad another six to twelve months of plumbing time into the project timeline is strongly motivated.

All of this assumes that there are few major hiccups in the process.  It assumes that no one in the private sector is going to court to challenge the rule making process, it assumes that the vast majority of the build-out is on time and close enough to scope, it assumes that the Supreme Court is cool with the changes.  It assumes a lot for a fast roll-out.

Minor Tweaks

All of the above is for a major revision of the US healthcare finance and delivery system.

What if we just build on what we have now?

Now that is easier.  A change to the ACA subsidy formula so that no one pays more than 10% of income for a silver plan can’t go live on January 1, 2020 as insurers are just about ready to submit final plans for approval next month.  But the rule making would come out via the routine Notice of Benefit and Payment Parameters in December and the plumbing would not be particularly complex.  These plans would definitely be available for the November 2020 open enrollment period with a go live date of January 1, 2021.

Moving Medicare’s age eligibility date up or down a year or two is also mechanically simple.

Changing Medicaid eligibility and financing so that the enhanced match rate applies to all mandatory populations or only to the new ACA populations but changing that guideline so it is now 167% FPL instead of 138% FPL is also fairly simple.  That is something that could readily go live at some point in 2020.  Creating well funded high cost reinsurance pools would also be a 2020 project.

Transition times are real.  They are not (just) attempts to push back problems past an election cycle.  There are real constraints that drive at least minimum transition periods.  The bigger and more complex the problem and change, the longer the pre-implementation period probably needs to be.

 

 

 

Previous Post: « On the Road and In Your Backyard
Next Post: Slush Funds for Pedophile Priests »

Reader Interactions

4Comments

  1. 1.

    Gelfling 545

    July 30, 2019 at 9:49 am

    Very informative. I just linked to it on FB for my simpler acquaintances who believe in a magic wand and for my deeper thinking acquaintances who have been wondering how the hell any of this could play out.

  2. 2.

    StringOnAStick

    July 30, 2019 at 11:51 am

    Surely the impressive finger wagging skill of a certain white haired Senator could cut through all this red tape and create Single Payer for all on day 1, 7 at the latest. /s.

    I posted a comment on another thread about a resistance group I went to right after the 2016 election; it was full of Single Payer or I will Withhold my Precious Vote types. I explained the Swiss and German systems, pointing out that there were insurance companies, all were covered and the insurance companies were very heavily regulated so no crap plans, no falling through the cracks. There were many looks of amazement, none of recognition about having heard about their systems. I don’t know how long ago it was on PBS, but TR Reid did a great series on how other countries run their health care and insurance systems; more people need to see that.

  3. 3.

    ronno2018

    July 30, 2019 at 3:54 pm

    I always really appreciate these detailed policy posts! Thanks!

  4. 4.

    Zelma

    July 30, 2019 at 6:03 pm

    Thank you for this. I wish more people who are looking for “simple, easy” solutions to the health care issue gave a moment’s thought to the fact that we are talking about one-sixth of the American economy. Think of the biggest ship in the world – how long does it take to turn it in a new direction? A real long time!

Comments are closed.

Primary Sidebar

Recent Comments

  • Kayla Rudbek on Holiday Prep Open Thread (Dec 14, 2019 @ 10:46am)
  • jeffreyw on Holiday Prep Open Thread (Dec 14, 2019 @ 10:45am)
  • gene108 on Holiday Prep Open Thread (Dec 14, 2019 @ 10:44am)
  • Dorothy A. Winsor on Holiday Prep Open Thread (Dec 14, 2019 @ 10:43am)
  • Betty Cracker on Holiday Prep Open Thread (Dec 14, 2019 @ 10:42am)

Support Our Site


Shopping Amazon via this link helps Balloon Juice...a lot

Balloon Juice Posts

View by Topic
View by Author
View by Month & Year

Featuring

John Cole
Silverman on Security
Impeachment Hearings
Anderson on Health Insurance
Dear WaterGirl

Calling All Jackals

Balloon Juice Meetups
Nominate a Rotating Tag
Submit Photos to On the Road
Site Feedback
Balloon Juice News

Johngcole avatarJohn Cole@Johngcole·
46m 1205865100336418821

New Post added at Balloon Juice - Holiday Prep Open Thread -https://www.balloon-juice.com/2019/12/14/holiday-prep-open-thread/

Twitter feed video.
Image for the Tweet beginning: New Post added at
Reply on Twitter 1205865100336418821Retweet on Twitter 1205865100336418821Like on Twitter 12058651003364188211Twitter 1205865100336418821
Johngcole avatarJohn Cole@Johngcole·
5h 1205795190830772224

New Post added at Balloon Juice - Saturday Morning Open Thread: Plan Your Calendar -

Balloon Juice | Saturday Morning Open Thread: Plan Your Calendar

MAJOR UPDATE: Demonstrations called for TUESDAY NIGHT! The vote on Articles of Impeachment is imminent. Join one of nearly 500 demonstrations nationwi...

www.balloon-juice.com

Reply on Twitter 1205795190830772224Retweet on Twitter 1205795190830772224Like on Twitter 12057951908307722243Twitter 1205795190830772224
Retweet on TwitterJohn Cole Retweeted
tressiemcphd avatarTressie McMillan Cottom@tressiemcphd·
10h 1205728637477179392

This is glorious. Glorious. https://twitter.com/yorkwhitaker/status/1205726859939303425

This is glorious. Glorious. https://t.co/rEQBKDN4Na
York Whitaker@YorkWhitaker

I love this app.

Reply on Twitter 1205728637477179392Retweet on Twitter 1205728637477179392286Like on Twitter 12057286374771793922327Twitter 1205728637477179392
Johngcole avatarJohn Cole@Johngcole·
12h 1205689726155591680

imagine caring what cenk uygar thinks... about anything

Reply on Twitter 1205689726155591680Retweet on Twitter 1205689726155591680Like on Twitter 120568972615559168029Twitter 1205689726155591680
Johngcole avatarJohn Cole@Johngcole·
13h 1205687690873724928

so just act normally?

Boing Boing@BoingBoing

Top Florida Cop instructed officer to act like a “white supremacist” when engaging Black suspect https://boingboing.net/2019/12/13/top-florida-cop-instructed-off.html

Reply on Twitter 1205687690873724928Retweet on Twitter 12056876908737249281Like on Twitter 120568769087372492829Twitter 1205687690873724928
Retweet on TwitterJohn Cole Retweeted
AllieGoertz avatarAllie Goertz@AllieGoertz·
14h 1205658316933750785

Now promise you’ll never drive your dad’s car drunk again, Matt. https://twitter.com/mattgaetz/status/1205644969513537542

Matt Gaetz@mattgaetz

If it’s any comfort...I can promise you’ll never have my last name. https://twitter.com/alliegoertz/status/1205627060258926592

Reply on Twitter 1205658316933750785Retweet on Twitter 12056583169337507851178Like on Twitter 120565831693375078520705Twitter 1205658316933750785
Retweet on TwitterJohn Cole Retweeted
NicoleHockley avatarNicole Hockley@NicoleHockley·
23h 1205524335873671169

Seven years ago started as a normal Friday morning.
After getting Dylan and Jake on the bus, I did chores until I left for an exercise class. While driving to class, I felt a sharp pain in my stomach, so bad that I almost pulled over to the side of the road, convinced I was...

Twitter feed video.
Image for the Tweet beginning: Seven years ago started as
Reply on Twitter 1205524335873671169Retweet on Twitter 12055243358736711697537Like on Twitter 120552433587367116926272Twitter 1205524335873671169
Johngcole avatarJohn Cole@Johngcole·
13h 1205682458034917377

New Post added at Balloon Juice - Do The Right Thing -

Balloon Juice | Do The Right Thing

I said this earlier on the twitter thing, and I want to say it here: Even if he is not convicted in the Senate and even if Dems pay a political price,...

www.balloon-juice.com

Reply on Twitter 1205682458034917377Retweet on Twitter 12056824580349173774Like on Twitter 120568245803491737710Twitter 1205682458034917377
Retweet on TwitterJohn Cole Retweeted
Johngcole avatarJohn Cole@Johngcole·
22h 1205551193977708545

Even if he is not convicted in the Senate and even if Dems pay a political price, impeaching Trump is the right thing to do because he’s a criminal who broke the laws. When everything is as broken as it is now, all you can do is do the right thing and hope for the best.

Reply on Twitter 1205551193977708545Retweet on Twitter 120555119397770854583Like on Twitter 1205551193977708545288Twitter 1205551193977708545
Johngcole avatarJohn Cole@Johngcole·
13h 1205679820052615169

shorter Matt Bevin- “Fuck you Kentucky have some murderers"

Reply on Twitter 1205679820052615169Retweet on Twitter 120567982005261516912Like on Twitter 120567982005261516955Twitter 1205679820052615169

Site Footer

Come for the politics, stay for the snark.

  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Comment Policy
  • Our Authors
  • Blogroll
  • Our Artists
  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2019 Dev Balloon Juice · All Rights Reserved · Powered by BizBudding Inc

Share this ArticleLike this article? Email it to a friend!

Email sent!