• Menu
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Before Header

  • About Us
  • Lexicon
  • Contact Us
  • Our Store
  • ↑
  • ↓
  • ←
  • →

Balloon Juice

Come for the politics, stay for the snark.

Come for the politics, stay for the snark.

Gastritis broke my calculator.

An almost top 10,000 blog!

No one could have predicted…

… makes me wish i had hoarded more linguine

This is a big f—–g deal.

Tick tock motherfuckers! Tick fucking tock!

Technically true, but collectively nonsense

Reality always lies in wait for … Democrats.

A snarling mass of vitriolic jackals

This is how realignments happen…

My years-long effort to drive family and friends away has really paid off this year.

Wow, I can’t imagine what it was like to comment in morse code.

You are either for trump or for democracy. Pick one.

They fucked up the fucking up of the fuckup!

I swear, each month of 2020 will have its own history degree.

We need fewer warriors in public service and more gardeners.

Militantly superior in their own minds…

Too inconsequential to be sued

Peak wingnut was a lie.

We survived Breitbartpocalypse!

Yes we did.

Reality always wins in the end.

No offense, but this thread hasn’t been about you for quite a while.

Mobile Menu

  • Look Forward & Back
  • Balloon Juice 2021 Pet Calendar
  • Site Feedback
  • All 2020 Fundraising
  • I Voted!
  • Take Action: Things We Can Do
  • Team Claire, and Family
  • Submit Photos to On the Road
  • BJ PayPal Donations
  • Politics
  • On The Road
  • Open Threads
  • Topics
  • Nature & Respite
  • Information As Power
  • COVID-19 Coronavirus
  • Authors
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Lexicon
  • Our Store
  • Politics
  • Open Threads
  • On The Road
  • Garden Chats
  • Nature & Respite
  • Look Forward & Back
You are here: Home / Anderson On Health Insurance / The billion dollar counterfactual

The billion dollar counterfactual

by David Anderson|  January 29, 20187:44 am| 5 Comments

This post is in: Anderson On Health Insurance, Meth Laboratories of Democracy

Facebook0Tweet0Email0

New York and Minnesota both run Section 1331 Basic Health Plans for people who make between 138% and 200% Federal Poverty Level (FPL) ($16588-24,040 for a single individual). This is an option from the ACA. The states filed a waiver that passes through 95% of the combined Advanced Premium Tax Credit (APTC) and Cost Sharing Reduction (CSR) that individuals would otherwise be entitled to. These states use this money to basically create an enhanced Medicaid program for this cohort. It provides lower premiums and lower deductibles than Exchange plans because these plans pay doctors and hospitals less.

New York and Minnesota approved rates for 2018 ACA plans on the basis of the actual risk pool. This means their ACA markets have a very small component of people who qualified for Silver plans with CSR. The weak Silver CSR bumps Silver plans from 70% nominal value to 73% actuarial value. Silver loading in these two states added an extra point or two to the rates. Similar states without BHPs added twenty or more points to their rates to cover the cost of CSR in the index rates.

The Trump Administration stopped paying CSR in October. The Trump Administration contends that the BHP payments should be reduced to the proportion of the BHP funding that could be directly attributed to APTC. This is leading to a billion dollar short fall in 2018 for the New York Essential Plan and a $100 million dollar or more gap for Minnesota.

And then the one thing that I am sure about the ACA occurred: There will be lots of lawyers. New York and Minnesota sued.

The New York and Minnesota #BHP lawsuit is herehttps://t.co/hC9kk4yTKN

Going to be a big fight on Actual vs. Counterfactual (I think counterfactual wins) pic.twitter.com/lsaEsTP1ws

— David Anderson (@bjdickmayhew) January 26, 2018

New York and Minnesota tried to file revised, Silver loaded rates as if their entire population was on the Exchange instead of in the BHP. They believe that the BHP calculation is based on the counterfactual of what would happen if the entire population was on Exchange. And from here, they estimate that if CSR had to be built into the rates, they would Silver Load and see a 20%-25% increase which would bring them even on net.

The Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) did not respond to this argument. Instead they are acting as if BHP funding is based on the actual and thus there is a billion dollar hole in the New York budget. From 2014-2017, the counterfactual and the factual are very close to each other and not worth fighting about.

I think BHP funding is based on the counterfactual. Here is the 2018 regulation for BHP funding:

Section 1331(d)(3)(A)(ii) of the
Affordable Care Act specifies that the payment determination shall take into account all relevant factors necessary to determine the value of the premium tax credits and CSRs that would have been provided to eligible individuals, including the age and income of the enrollee, whether the enrollment is for self-only or family coverage, geographic differences in average spending for health care across rating areas, the health status of the enrollee for purposes of determining risk adjustment payments and reinsurance payments that would have been made if the enrollee had enrolled in a qualified health plan through an Exchange, and whether any reconciliation of PTC and CSR would have occurred if the enrollee had been so enrolled. This payment methodology takes each of these factors into account. [my dual emphasis]

“Would have been provided” implies a counterfactual. We are supposed to imagine the New York and Minnesota markets as if there was no BHP. From here,a projection of premiums is made. And from that premium projection, the number of people who earn between 138% and 200% FPL is calculated. That number is then discounted by 5% to act as the maximum pass-through to the state for their BHP.

“individuals” is the second key word. Everyone agrees that the individual is entitled to CSR benefits. The federal government has argued in court that Silver loading is an acceptable practice if insurers are not to be reimbursed for CSR benefits to individuals.

New York and Minnesota are arguing that they were not treated fairly by CMS compared to all other states that Silver Loaded. CMS is paying on the factual instead of the counterfactual for no good reason despite their own regulations saying that the BHP payment is a counterfactual payment.

There will be a lot of lawyers involved, but I think the counterfactual will eventually win.

Facebook0Tweet0Email0
Previous Post: « Monday Morning Open Thread: (Fighting for) Respect
Next Post: Noisy Desperation »

Reader Interactions

5Comments

  1. 1.

    p.a.

    January 29, 2018 at 8:40 am

    eventually win. meaning a timeframe of ? and meanwhile, the $ comes from ?

  2. 2.

    NobodySpecial

    January 29, 2018 at 8:51 am

    Does it go to the Supremes? If so, then I have no confidence in the law being applied correctly. The Supreme Court is a failed institution since Bush v. Gore.

  3. 3.

    Geeno

    January 29, 2018 at 9:25 am

    Counterfactuals always win in the Trump era

  4. 4.

    Raoul

    January 29, 2018 at 11:50 am

    As a Minnesotan, I sure hope you’re right, David! Thank you for spelling it out in understandable terms.

  5. 5.

    carla

    January 29, 2018 at 9:41 pm

    In Minnesota we call this “Minnesota Care,” or MN Care. I am on it. What a Godsend. I have known that this state and New York are the only states to offer this kind of health insurance. I work in the tourism economy in NE MN’s Arrowhead country (that’s the north shore of Lake Superior), more than full-time hours from May through October and part-time hours across the winter. I also have my 94 yr. old mother living with me. So wonderful to have health insurance. I pay an affordable premium each month and have a co-pay for specific visits to the local clinic. I am hopeful David is right.

Comments are closed.

Primary Sidebar

Biden-Harris Inauguration

Biden-Harris Inauguration Website

Official events – watch at top link

Kakistocracy
I believe In My Fellow Americans
Defeat Them
Turning Bystanders Into Activists
First Up, COVID

Do Something!

Call Your Senators & Representatives
Directory of US Senators
Directory of US Representatives
Letter to Elected Officials – Albatrossity
Letter to Elected Officials – Martin

I Got the Shot!

🎈Ways to Support Our Site

Become a Balloon Juice Patreon
Donate with Venmo, Zelle or PayPal
Shop Amazon via this link to support Balloon Juice ⬇  

Recent Comments

  • NotMax on COVID-19 Coronavirus Updates: Wednesday/Thursday, Jan. 20-21 (Jan 21, 2021 @ 5:44am)
  • sab on COVID-19 Coronavirus Updates: Wednesday/Thursday, Jan. 20-21 (Jan 21, 2021 @ 5:42am)
  • OzarkHillbilly on COVID-19 Coronavirus Updates: Wednesday/Thursday, Jan. 20-21 (Jan 21, 2021 @ 5:39am)
  • YY_Sima Qian on COVID-19 Coronavirus Updates: Wednesday/Thursday, Jan. 20-21 (Jan 21, 2021 @ 5:36am)
  • Chyron HR on COVID-19 Coronavirus Updates: Wednesday/Thursday, Jan. 20-21 (Jan 21, 2021 @ 5:31am)

Team Claire, and Family

Help for David’s Niece Claire
Claire Updates
Claire update for the holidays 12/23

Balloon Juice Posts

View by Topic
View by Author
View by Month & Year

Featuring

John Cole
Silverman on Security
COVID-19 Coronavirus
Medium Cool with BGinCHI
Information Is Power

Calling All Jackals

Site Feedback
Submit Photos to On the Road
Nominate a Rotating Tag
Meetups: Proof of Life
2021 Pets of Balloon Juice Calendar

Culture: Books, Film, TV, Music, Games, Podcasts

Noir: Favorites in Film, Books, TV
Book Recommendations & Indy Recs
Mystery Recommendations
Medium Cool: What If (Books & Films)
Netflix Favorites
Amazon Prime Favorites
Netflix Suggestions in July
Fun Music Thread
Longmire & Netflix Suggestions
Medium Cool: Places!
Medium Cool: Games!
Medium Cool: Watch or Read Again

Twitter

John Cole’s Twitter

[custom-twitter-feeds]

Site Footer

Come for the politics, stay for the snark.

  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Comment Policy
  • Our Authors
  • Blogroll
  • Our Artists
  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2021 Dev Balloon Juice · All Rights Reserved · Powered by BizBudding Inc

Share this ArticleLike this article? Email it to a friend!

Email sent!