• Menu
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Before Header

  • About Us
  • Lexicon
  • Contact Us
  • Our Store
  • ↑
  • ↓
  • ←
  • →

Balloon Juice

Come for the politics, stay for the snark.

They traffic in fear. it is their only currency. if we are fearful, they are winning.

I swear, each month of 2020 will have its own history degree.

I’m going back to the respite thread.

This fight is for everything.

Tick tock motherfuckers! Tick fucking tock!

Shelter in place is one thing. shelter in pants is quite another.

Women: they get shit done

An almost top 10,000 blog!

All this crying. this is why i don’t click on stuff.

Let’s delete this post and never speak of this again.

I personally stopped the public option…

I’m only here for the duck photos.

Yes we did.

This blog goes to 11…

I’d like to think you all would remain faithful to me if i ever tried to have some of you killed.

The revolution will be supervised.

Something seems odd about that, but i have been drinking.

Perhaps you mistook them for somebody who gives a damn – Nancy Pelosi

It was down to kool-aid drinkers and next of kin at the trump White House

It’s not even safe to go out and pick up 2 days worth of poop anymore.

People are complicated. Love is not.

Reality always wins in the end.

This really is a full service blog.

We have all the best words.

Mobile Menu

  • Look Forward & Back
  • Balloon Juice 2021 Pet Calendar
  • Site Feedback
  • All 2020 Fundraising
  • I Voted!
  • Take Action: Things We Can Do
  • Team Claire, and Family
  • Submit Photos to On the Road
  • BJ PayPal Donations
  • Politics
  • On The Road
  • Open Threads
  • Topics
  • Nature & Respite
  • Information As Power
  • COVID-19 Coronavirus
  • Authors
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Lexicon
  • Our Store
  • Politics
  • Open Threads
  • Garden Chats
  • On The Road
  • Nature & Respite
  • Look Forward & Back
You are here: Home / Anderson On Health Insurance / Improving Meaningful difference

Improving Meaningful difference

by David Anderson|  July 21, 20167:01 am| 3 Comments

This post is in: Anderson On Health Insurance, Fuck The Poor, Hillary Clinton 2016

Facebook0Tweet0Email0

Jed Graham raises a good point at IBD on the problems of medicaid managed care providers spamming the exchanges in Mississippi:

A closer look at Centene’s much-heralded success reveals that competition between insurers on the ObamaCare exchanges has become toxic. Rather than being a boon to consumers looking for a good deal, competition is hurting the very people it is supposed to help…

only 40% of the subsidy-eligible exchange population is enrolled in Mississippi, putting it dead last among states which didn’t expand Medicaid and, therefore, cater to a more heavily subsidized group.

Yet the fallout was entirely predictable. Although subsidies are pegged to the premium of the second-lowest-cost silver plan in each market, Centene has been scrunching down its silver premiums by making the plans more bronzelike…. That in turns shrinks the government subsidies that are supposed to help make coverage affordable. If customers can’t afford, or don’t like, the cheap Centene silver plans on offer, they’ll have less of a subsidy to buy a bronze plan or a silver plan from a competitor.

In the largest HealthCare.gov market in 37 states, the second cheapest silver plan costs, on average, 27% more than the cheapest bronze plan this year. But in Mississippi, where Centene’s Ambetter brand is the low-cost provider, the gap between bronze and silver is only 12.6% in 2016, down from 34.8% in 2015.

Ambetter/Centene has adapted a Silver spam strategy that has been a hobby horse of mine for a while.  The goal is to proliferate a bunch of plans tightly clustered around the subsidy benchmark point.  For markets where all insurers are paying near commercial rates, this is not a big deal.  In markets where one insurer is paying Medicaid plus something or Medicare like rates and everyone else is paying commercial rates to providers, this is a big deal. It forces heavily subsidized buyers to choose between half a dozen affordable plans that are functionally similar from the same insurer or not really be able to afford a choice.

This is due to the lack of good meaningful difference regulation.  Currently Meaingful Difference regulation is a farce.

One of six characteristics has to change for CMS to consider a cloned plan to be meaningfully different (from the 2015 regulations where we first saw this strategy explode).

The key characteristics were proposed in paragraphs (b)(1)–(b)(7), and include (1) cost sharing; (2) provider networks; (3) covered benefits (including prescription drugs); (4) plan type (for example, HMO or PPO); (5) premiums; (6) health savings account eligibility; and (7) selfonly, non-self-only, or child-only coverage offerings. We proposed that, at a minimum, a reasonable consumer would have to be able to identify two or more of the characteristics proposed at § 156.298(b) as different in order for the plan to pass the meaningful difference test…

To address concerns with the proposed meaningful difference standard, we have modified § 156.298(b) to have the standard set at one material difference rather than two, and have removed premiums as one of the characteristics among which plans must be different.

There are two ways to avoid the Silver Spam problem. The first is to have an active buyer exchange. Covered California allows insurers to offer a single product cluster to be introduced into a market. A single insurer can offer multiple products (see yesterday’s post on San Francisco for an example) if there is significant space between the two products in design and pricing).

That solution can work in states that have their own Exchanges and more importantly the political will to fight insurance companies.

A more straightforward solution is available. Fix the meaningful difference regulation as well as build better decision support tools into Healthcare.gov. CMS can do this in their normal rule making operations. I think it was not done as a means of getting good headlines on how low cost the exchange plans have been.

There are two types of fixes to the regulation. The first could be a set of check boxes. — a plan is meaningfully different if it has three elements different from its peers or four elements or two elements or whatever number of elements. One or two elements still allows for significant gaming. Three or four elements would get rid of most of the clones. I would also be inclined to mandate a standard benefit package (ie a Silver has a $X deductible, Y% co-insurance and A/B/C co-pays for drugs etc) as that is the cheapest area for an insurer to tweak things to beat a regulation.

The second is a bit more open ended. For a reference individual (I like using the 40 year old non-smoker with no dependents), a plan offered by the same insurer is meaningfully different if the premiums vary by Z percent. That Z could be 3% or 5% or 7%. After that, CMS would not care how the difference is achieved? Is it a PPO instead of an EPO? Who cares? Is it a narrow network versus a broad network? Who cares? Is it HSA eligible or not HSA eligible? Who cares?

The insurance companies could then design products where there actually is a useful difference in the products instead of attempts to game/hack the subsidy formula for business strategy reasons.

The decision support tools would require a standard format to allow a buyer to compare the (far fewer) plans offered by a single insurer in a single band. Mayhew Silver Value HMO is different than Mayhew Silver SuperDuper PPO in these 3 key elements of network, out of network benefits and PCP gatekeeping. Buying Mayhew Silver SuperDuper PPO will cost you 25% more.

This reduces information complexity for the buyer as it gets rid of a number of isomorphic clones while increasing the probability that there is a meaningful and realistic set of practical choices for subsidized buyers. The downside is that this will increase the cost to the federal government as advanced premium tax credit payments will increase. I am fine with that.

Facebook0Tweet0Email0
Previous Post: « Thursday Morning Open Thread
Next Post: What in the Wide World of Fuck… »

Reader Interactions

3Comments

  1. 1.

    rikyrah

    July 21, 2016 at 7:19 am

    Mayhew, Mississippi is one of those states that refused to expand Medicaid. They really are not about helping their citizens.
    You know. …state’s rights and all.

  2. 2.

    rikyrah

    July 21, 2016 at 7:23 am

    Political will to fight insurance companies?

    BWA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA

    When the GOP talks about buying insurance across state boundaries, they never include GOOD regulatory oversight. The thought that MS would have anything remotely approaching good oversight. ….

    Nope.

  3. 3.

    Richard Mayhew

    July 21, 2016 at 7:39 am

    @rikyrah: yep, that is why it would be a federal requirement

Comments are closed.

Primary Sidebar

Do Something!

Call Your Senators & Representatives
Directory of US Senators
Directory of US Representatives

Vaccine Venting (latest)
Vaccine Venting (all)

I Got the Shot (latest thread)
I Got the Shot! (all)

Take Your Shot – Explain the %

🎈Ways to Support Our Site

Become a Balloon Juice Patreon
Donate with Venmo, Zelle or PayPal
Shop Amazon via this link to support Balloon Juice ⬇  

Recent Comments

  • trollhattan on Press Briefing: Jen Psaki and Dr. Fauci (Apr 13, 2021 @ 1:32pm)
  • Fair Economist on J&J Pause (Apr 13, 2021 @ 1:27pm)
  • germy on Press Briefing: Jen Psaki and Dr. Fauci (Apr 13, 2021 @ 1:27pm)
  • different-church-lady on Press Briefing: Jen Psaki and Dr. Fauci (Apr 13, 2021 @ 1:23pm)
  • different-church-lady on Press Briefing: Jen Psaki and Dr. Fauci (Apr 13, 2021 @ 1:22pm)

Team Claire, and Family

Claire Updates
Claire is Home!

Balloon Juice Posts

View by Topic
View by Author
View by Month & Year

Featuring

John Cole
Silverman on Security
COVID-19 Coronavirus
Medium Cool with BGinCHI
Furry Friends

Calling All Jackals

Site Feedback
Submit Photos to On the Road
Nominate a Rotating Tag
Meetups: Proof of Life
2021 Pets of Balloon Juice Calendar

Culture: Books, Film, TV, Music, Games, Podcasts

Noir: Favorites in Film, Books, TV
Book Recommendations & Indy Recs
Mystery Recommendations
Netflix Favorites
Amazon Prime Favorites
Netflix Suggestions in July
Longmire & Netflix Suggestions

Twitter

John Cole’s Twitter

[custom-twitter-feeds]

Site Footer

Come for the politics, stay for the snark.

  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Comment Policy
  • Our Authors
  • Blogroll
  • Our Artists
  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2021 Dev Balloon Juice · All Rights Reserved · Powered by BizBudding Inc

Share this ArticleLike this article? Email it to a friend!

Email sent!