At Least They Didn’t Shoot Him
via videosift.com
Someone tell Rudy Giuliani to shut up.
July 31, 2009 5:38 pm
Posted in: Domestic Affairs, The War on Your Neighbor, aka the War on Drugs
58 Comments
Someone tell Rudy Giuliani to shut up.
July 31, 2009 5:38 pm
Posted in: Domestic Affairs, The War on Your Neighbor, aka the War on Drugs
58 Comments
58 Responses
Zifnab - July 31, 2009 | 5:46 pm · Link
Wow. They weren’t even subtle about it.
J.W. Hamner - July 31, 2009 | 5:53 pm · Link
When an officer of the law plants drugs on you, you should just say “yes sir” and “no sir”... it’s what I would hypothetically do since there’s no chance it will happen to my privileged white ass.
KG - July 31, 2009 | 5:57 pm · Link
fun game to play with the “I don’t trust the government” wingnut…
Balloon Juice Commenter: So, you don’t trust the government?
Wingnut: Fuck no.
BJC: so, you don’t trust the police?
Wingnut: of course I trust the police.
BJC: you realize, the police are part of the government, right?
Wingnut: So?
BJC: well, if the government can’t do anything right, then it follows that the police can’t do anything right
Wingnut: No, the police are always right
BJC: so, the government is always right?
Wingnut: No, just the police.
BJC: Well, clearly, you cannot choose the wine in front of you.
freelancer - July 31, 2009 | 5:57 pm · Link
In the Related videos, Retarded deputy sheriff dumps a quadriplegic out of his wheelchair on the floor
http://www.break.com/index/cop.....floor.html
Good Grief.
I hope it really sucks to be a cop on the beat after this Gates shit.
c u n d gulag - July 31, 2009 | 5:59 pm · Link
This can’t be news to anyone? Can this?
The amazing thing is how stupid these cops may have been.
Who’s the Employment Agency lately for all of these stupid cops?
Keystone?
General Winfield Stuck - July 31, 2009 | 6:00 pm · Link
And I’d bet dollars to donuts this whole sorry spectacle will be deemed appropriate police conduct somewhere somehow. Nothing is more suspect than clear video evidence, so it seems form past incidents like this, where actually if you look at it from a different angle, the cop could have been slipping him some coin to make bail. Also.
JenJen - July 31, 2009 | 6:03 pm · Link
It’s moments like these where I thank the heavens above for giving us this thing called “Lawyers.”
Tom - July 31, 2009 | 6:03 pm · Link
If one thing is clear, cameras mounted on police cars need to be removed. Keep on movin’.
steve s - July 31, 2009 | 6:04 pm · Link
that cop was Concern Trolling the crap outta that guy.
Comrade Dread - July 31, 2009 | 6:15 pm · Link
Frankly, I’m rather amazed that they didn’t turn the camera off or otherwise ‘accidentally’ find a way to make that footage unviewable.
WyldPirate - July 31, 2009 | 6:15 pm · Link
there are no word to describe how much i despise law eforcement officers.
freelancer - July 31, 2009 | 6:18 pm · Link
AND
Clearly, this is how realignments happen.
beltane - July 31, 2009 | 6:22 pm · Link
But, but, Obama is a Kenyan-Hawaiian Muslim and you can’t prove otherwise. If you cherished our precious freedoms you would bow before every cop you saw. If that guy was really innocent, the cops wouldn’t have messed with him.
As a teenager, my husband spent a couple of years in Venezuela where this shit was a regular fact of life. Everyone, even the rich, lived in fear of corrupt cops.
Cat Lady - July 31, 2009 | 6:25 pm · Link
Why is this any of this a surprise to anybody? The bullies and troublemakers I knew in high school are either cops or tried to be cops. Who wants to be a cop? People who like to be in and around trouble. Cops are to _ as volunteer firefighters are to arsonists. Duh.
Maybe if the good cops ratted out the bad cops, instead of covering for them, we’d get somewhere.
As far as Rudy’s pearls of wisdom, let’s talk about his awesome Florida strategy. Palin/Rudy 2012.
eric - July 31, 2009 | 6:25 pm · Link
I suspect it is because these men are Darwinists, socialists, relativists, and otherwise non-believers in baby jeebus’ miraculous birth.
Joking aside: as an atheist and generally kind and decent human being, i chafe at the everloudening insistence that I am the one lacking morals. Really?
eff them.
eric
Bad Horse's Filly - July 31, 2009 | 6:29 pm · Link
What should be a real indicator of how the police think, is that they do this stuff knowing there are dash-cams recording it.
There’s video (which at the moment I can’t find the link, but it was on the major networks) of cops falsifying a report on a woman when a cop hit her car. They started by accusing her of being drunk (she wasn’t) and went on from there. It’s all on tape.
Note to John: RSS feed isn’t working now. Also.
Comrade Dread - July 31, 2009 | 6:30 pm · Link
@KG
Yeah, I’ve had the conversation with wingnuts so many times it makes my head hurt thinking about it.
Apparently, you give a government employee a badge and a weapon and they stop being petty incompetent power hungry boobs and become someone who must be bowed before.
eric - July 31, 2009 | 6:33 pm · Link
Part of it is the gun worship. You cant be that bad of a person if you are allowed to carry a gun everywhere.
eric
John S. - July 31, 2009 | 6:34 pm · Link
The worst part about Gates-gate is that there was a teaching opportunity, but it sailed right over the heads of everyone obsessed with the race bullshit.
There is a serious rot within this country’s law enforcement. Too many police officers clearly DO NOT understand their role, because they style themselves some sort of authoritarian masters rather than enforcers of the fucking law. I reckon they have seen Judge Dredd one too many times and think to themselves, “I AM THE LAW.”
No, assholes, you are not the law. See what your fucking squad car says on the side there? SERVE AND PROTECT. The citizens do not exist to serve YOU and your authoritarian fantasies, and we’re not supposed to need protection FROM you.
Get back to doing the job you’re supposed to be doing, you motherfuckers.
monkeyboy - July 31, 2009 | 7:02 pm · Link
I used to think this BS was on the decline. But then came 9/11 and the subsequent fear mongering. Approval of a police state then took a large uptick.
HumboldtBlue - July 31, 2009 | 7:04 pm · Link
Umm, just fucking wow. I have little if no love for our brothers in blue bedecked in the badges and armed with their blunderbusses, but as a proud union member and a former firefighter, that’s just fucking wrong.
As the noted philosopher Ice Cube put it so wonderfully … Fuck the police!
TR - July 31, 2009 | 7:14 pm · Link
They were just looking for his birth certificate.
ericvsthem - July 31, 2009 | 7:28 pm · Link
Conservatives love authority, includes the police, CIA, NSA, military, and the FBI (but not the ATF cuz they TOOK ARR GUNZ). They hate effete government bureaucrats because they know that those guys can fuck up your life WAY MORE than someone packing heat and carrying a badge.
Personally, I’m amazed those pigs didn’t tase him or smack him with a billy club.
Those criminals will get a slap on the wrist and keep their badges. The victim will wind up having spent more time behind bars.
Just keep walking. Also.
Fulcanelli - July 31, 2009 | 7:31 pm · Link
Hey, just think… That’s how they treat a white guy, one of their own tribe.
Imagine.
ericvsthem - July 31, 2009 | 7:34 pm · Link
@Fulcanelli: That guy wasn’t white.
inkadu - July 31, 2009 | 7:34 pm · Link
@General Winfield Stuck: And I’d bet dollars to donuts this whole sorry spectacle will be deemed appropriate police conduct somewhere somehow.
No. More likely every drug arrest any of these officers made will be overturned.
Something similar happened in New Haven, CT, and it was a god damned legal nightmare.
And it’s yet another reason why most drugs should be decriminalized. It’s much harder to plant a dead body on someone during a traffic stop.
Ella in NM - July 31, 2009 | 7:40 pm · Link
Ever since the Gates fiasco started being framed only as a “racial’ incident, I have had to keep myself from throwing a beer bottle at my TV screen every time I hear them blithering idiots on cable news. Yes, race may have played some part in that incident, but it is clear that this was more than that, and NO ONE’s TALKING ABOUT IT. It’s because the little candy-asses still think that that kind of thing could never happen to THEM. It’s about abuse of power, sense of entitlement, and the kind of people we are hiring to be cops.
Two years ago, a local white guy (who just happens to own a pretty nice small business and so had the means to consult a civil attorney) sued our city police for for violating his constitutional rights and other injuries and WON a half-million dollars. What for? He yelled “bitch!” at a woman who nearly rammed her car into him trying to beat him to a parking place at the Target. One of our city’s finest—who seemed to forget he was off duty at the time—decided he didn’t like that language, swaggered up to him as he was entering the store, and told the guy to watch his mouth or he’d have to cite him. When the man wasn’t sufficiently deferent, Supercop arrested the guy for disorderly conduct and then added resisting arrest after he argued with him that he had broken no laws. For good measure, he threw the man on the ground and tore his rotator cuff putting him in handcuffs.
This crap with more and more cops acting like they’re frigging omnipotent enforcers has been going on for a long time, but it definitely has gotten WAY worse over the past 8 years with the fear-based 911 “uber-justification” for all government overuse of authority. Now they are basically being trained to think like scared victims in every setting, rather than to develop good judgement and interpersonal communication and conflict resolution skills.
The only way this shit will change is when these people to sue the friggin’ pants off cops and cities.
Fulcanelli - July 31, 2009 | 7:42 pm · Link
@ericvsthem: Huh? What is he? “High Yella” black? Foxtrot Tango Whiskey. I give up.
AhabTRuler - July 31, 2009 | 7:44 pm · Link
BINGO!
AhabTRuler - July 31, 2009 | 7:46 pm · Link
Uh, there’s a link under that BINGO, dammit!
Mnemosyne - July 31, 2009 | 7:49 pm · Link
I can’t help but wonder if this has anything to do with the fact that a significant minority of cops are also National Guardsmen who have been sent to Iraq and Afghanistan. The cop in Oakland who shot the guy in the back (claiming that he mixed up his gun and his Taser) was an Iraq veteran.
How many of these guys are coming back with major PTSD and/or closed head injuries? Who got hired to take their place while they were overseas? If the Army has had to resort to recruiting convicted criminals and illiterates, I can just imagine the winners that have been applying for the police force.
fliegr - July 31, 2009 | 7:58 pm · Link
String those cop motherfuckers up, and give that worthless woman-beater enough money so his girlfriend stays around to spend it. I’ve about had it with authoritarians in this country.
Hammy - July 31, 2009 | 8:02 pm · Link
In related news, cops in Hollywood, FL are caught on tape discussing how they will falsify a police report to blame a woman for a car accident in which they are at fault.
As a result of this coming out, the woman’s charges were dropped, the cops are suspended and may be fired, and criminal defense attorneys are going through their case files to see if any of the tainted cops played a role in the arrest/investigation. If so, they will argue that those cops are known to falsify police records and can’t be trusted. Ever.
AhabTRuler - July 31, 2009 | 8:03 pm · Link
Unfortunately, the authoritarians have also had it with YOU!
freelancer - July 31, 2009 | 8:06 pm · Link
@Mnemosyne:
You make a good point about veterans on the force, also:
There’s Soldiering: Engaging and defeating an enemy through use of military force, and then occupying his territory.
And then there’s Policing. Somebody needs to inform police in this country that there’s a difference.
There has long been a prolonged, systemic failure of law enforcement to see itself as a policing agency, and not as a militaristic institution.
http://www.theagitator.com/200.....partments/
School police being given M-16s? Local cops acquiring Blackhawks and Hueys? No wonder there’s a mentality of:
“This is a war. We are soldiers. Death can come for us at any place, at any time. ZOMGZ! That woman has Knitting Needles!”
General Winfield Stuck - July 31, 2009 | 8:11 pm · Link
@inkadu:
Wut? I would hope so. Anyways, I hope your right. The video looks incriminating, but beyond a reasonable doubt, or even more likely than not. We shall see. The cop lawyers have debunking apparent clear convincing dashcam evidence down to a science.
ericvsthem - July 31, 2009 | 8:16 pm · Link
@Fulcanelli:
Carlos is black, check this link and watch the video:
http://www.wsmv.com/news/15370841/detail.html
This story is also over a year old.
The officer who planted the drugs was cleared on charges, and it’s possible that Carlos Ferrell was indeed carrying the marijuana.
http://www.putnampit.com/ferrell_lawsuit.pdf
Brick Oven Bill - July 31, 2009 | 8:17 pm · Link
Take it easy on Rudy, Rahm told him to shut up too. Rahm was yelling and jumping around though.
General Winfield Stuck - July 31, 2009 | 8:21 pm · Link
Of course he was. And the beat goes on.
Jody - July 31, 2009 | 8:22 pm · Link
The rest of you need to stop posting until you’ve given proper deference to the Princess Bride reference KG left up in #3.
Kudos sir. Very well done indeed.
inkadu - July 31, 2009 | 8:25 pm · Link
@freelancer: Do the bobbies still just carry their night sticks? Might not be a bad idea to go back to that. Cops are pretty good at getting people down on the ground, and the tazers should take care of the truly problematic cases.
I’m in Argentina now. In the 80’s the cops (technically, they’re not cops, but gendarmeria, which is military, but they often patrol the streets. ) used to carry submachine guns. Now they carry shotguns. Really? Could they carry weapons any MORE likely to damage innocent bystanders? I can only think of flamethrowers and grenades.
@General Winfield Stuck: The case in New Haven was a federal case, with federal investigators who Knew Their Shit and had incontrevertible evidence… so you might be right, they might get off. But if they do, someone needs to open up a can of vigilante justice on them.
General Winfield Stuck - July 31, 2009 | 8:33 pm · Link
@inkadu:
They did get off. see
@ericvsthem:
freelancer - July 31, 2009 | 8:41 pm · Link
@inkadu:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EZnEpaSOFwk
England never quite had that second amendment.
inkadu - July 31, 2009 | 8:43 pm · Link
@Jody: Hey, he snuck it in at the very last line, so I missed. If you really wanted to do Princess Bride it up it would go something like,
inkadu - July 31, 2009 | 8:54 pm · Link
@General Winfield Stuck: There is something very weird about that story. Why was his ex-wife involved on a 90-mile-an-hour chase? It’s weird. I wonder what happened to the excessive force charges, though. The story doesn’t mention those.
Holger Awakens - July 31, 2009 | 9:07 pm · Link
Rudy telling Obama to “shut up” is the best advice this immature campaigner has received since he took office. Let’s see if he’s man enough to heed it.
Anne Laurie - July 31, 2009 | 9:46 pm · Link
See, that’s the thing: For all the morons, bigots, authoritarians and thugs-with-badges, there are also plenty of decent, hard-working professionals trying to do a difficult job well. Dashboard cameras give the professionals another slight edge over their more-enthusiastic-than-ethical comrades, as well as against the sort of upstanding citizen who’s all in favor of cops kickin’ arse ‘n takin’ names fvck yeah! until it’s them some donut-sucking pig stops for blowing thru a red light… at 93 mph… after running over a three-year-old leukemia victim’s puppy… while scoring a .35 on the blood-alcohol test.
But I gotta agree that decriminalization would reduce the burden on honest law enforcement professionals greatly. Again, the Good Cops know that the War on Selected Drugs Selectively Applied is a giant waste of time, money & lives—as well as giving the Bad Cops waaay too many routes to cut corners and fvck up everybodys’ lives.
celticdragon - July 31, 2009 | 10:13 pm · Link
Freelancer
Home Invasion.
http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-8742091.html
There has been lotsa stuff the past 8 years or so in the MSM of violent home robberies in the UK. Unfortunately, courts there are no longer recognizing an inherent right to self defense even using household items, it seems…
More here…
http://www.reason.com/news/show/28582.html
Jody - August 1, 2009 | 12:00 am · Link
Inkadu:
applause
standing ovation
jenniebee - August 1, 2009 | 12:51 am · Link
I know I keep flogging this but Oklahoma cop assaults EMTs taking a patient to the hospital
If anybody’s curious, the paramedics have said that they weren’t running the lights and sirens because the woman was having chest pains, and while that is an urgent and emergency situation, it isn’t good for the patient to run sirens if he or she might be having a heart attack.
Brachiator - August 1, 2009 | 12:57 am · Link
@Bad Horse’s Filly:
The issue isn’t simply race or racial profiling or a supposedly arrogant black man making a poor white cop feel bad by insisting on his rights in his own home. The issue is civil liberties. The issue is authoritarian cops. The issue is a craven segment of the public who insist on giving cops “the benefit of the doubt” to excuse police misconduct.
Here are the cops framing a woman for a DUI.
http://www.nbcmiami.com/news/l.....Crash.html
There’s no way that the woman in this incident can be described as arrogant. There is no way that she can be accused of disobeying the cops’ instructions. The cops, including a community affairs officer, conspire to frame her because protecting the brotherhood of cops is more important than serving the public.
Here are some other key parts of the story:
Civilian Community Service Officer Karim Thomas joins the three senior officers and the four cops go so far as to change the angle of pictures of the accident to make it look like Torrensvilas swerved in front of the cop car and caused the accident, not Francisco.
Throughout the tape, the cops acknowledged what they are doing is illegal, but when you are the law, there is nothing wrong with bending it for a fellow cop, one says.
“I don’t lie and make things up ever because it’s wrong, but if I need to bend it a little bit to protect a cop, I’ll do it,” Pressley tells Francisco after reassuring him no one will ever find out. “She’s freaking hammered anyway.”
The cops even do a final rehearsal before Villa is taken to the city lock up.
“We’ll take care of it,” one officer says. The others reply: “We’re good.
jenniebee - August 1, 2009 | 1:12 am · Link
@Comrade Dread:
Frankly, I’m rather amazed that they didn’t turn the camera off or otherwise ‘accidentally’ find a way to make that footage unviewable.
It’s disturbing the things they can do with the dashcam on that are very difficult to explain to unsympathetic juries. For one, if a cop wants to start piling up bogus charges, he can “rake” a target with the barest edge of his flashlight. If he does it in certain places – sternum, across the top of the hips – it causes an involuntary reaction and a whole lot of pain. The involuntary flinch, however, is assault or resisting arrest or anything else the cop wants it to be. Cops will puposely ratchet a handcuff too tight and then twist, or put a knee on your back. It’s painful, it’s hard to breathe, and the instinctive response is to struggle, but struggling is resisting arrest.
dieter - August 1, 2009 | 1:14 am · Link
Wow. Just….wow. It’s really effing obvious from the video that the cop withdrew an object from his shirt pocket, put the same object in the pants pocket of the suspect, and immediately pulled the very same object out of the suspect’s pants pocket and declared it to be marijuana.
Even a kindergartener could follow the action and understand what’s going on.
Which means that the chances rise to about 2% that a jury in Cookesville, Tennessee may convict this police officer of any form of misconduct.
Glocksman - August 1, 2009 | 2:43 am · Link
@Anne Laurie:
Again, the Good Cops know that the War on Selected Drugs Selectively Applied is a giant waste of time, money & lives
Back during the early 1990’s I attended a ‘citizen’s academy’ held by the local police.
One of the officers who was teaching us was a Captain (a fairly high rank given the size of Evansville’s Police Department) and he told the entire group that in his opinion most of the drug laws dealing with ‘lesser’ drugs such as marijuana not only should be repealed, but will at some point in the future simply because they’ll prove to be unenforceable.
Over the years I’ve had my share of run ins with local law enforcement, from being arrested for stealing hubcaps when I was 18 to multiple speeding infractions in my 20’s.
The biggest asshole cop I ever dealt with was the one in an unmarked car who pulled me over for speeding.
First off, in Indiana at the time only uniformed police or police in marked police vehicles could legally issue citations.
This cop was in a suit and driving a plain jane Crown Vic.
When he threatened to arrest me and tow my car in, I pointed out that he didn’t have the authority to do so given Indiana law.
When I said that, he wigged out and started waving one of those big Mag-Lites at me and threatening to ‘kick my ass right here’.
Thank God I pulled over in a hospital parking lot and it just happened to be shift change.
There must have been 20 people watching this performance, which in retrospect was probably the only thing saving me from a serious beatdown or even being inadvertently killed.
Though as luck would have it, it was the same hospital my mother worked at and a couple of her co-workers recognized me and informed her of what happened.
It took everything I had to persuade her to just drop it because the cop in question had a lot of political juice and any complaints would probably backfire given the nature of Evansville’s ‘good old boy’ politics.
As it is, I escaped with no ticket and no arrest but that incident led me to give much more credence to allegations of police abuse than I would have prior to it.
The irony is that the cop who actually arrested me for my sole criminal (the hubcap bit) incident treated me with respect and answered all of my babbling ‘what’s going to happen’ questions truthfully.
In other words, while I didn’t like being busted I had no one to blame but myself and the arresting officer was simply being professional.
Similarly, when I got pulled over a couple of years later for doing ‘115 and accelerating’ in a 45 zone on US 41, the state trooper simply laughed when I stuttered out (I was scared shitless and it showed) ‘N.N.No sir, my speedometer doesn’t go that high*’ when he asked me if I knew how fast I was going.
The trooper said that he could arrest me on the spot (true) but that he was going to take it easy on me and cite me for my average speed of 79 in the 45 zone instead of the 115 and accelerating that the plane above clocked me at.
I didn’t like the ticket, but the trooper was professional for the most part and didn’t overreact.
*The car was a mid 70’s Caprice big block, but the speedo only went to 100.
bob h - August 1, 2009 | 6:59 am · Link
With the ratcheting down of terrorism fear-mongering by Obama, Giuliani Associates presumably is looking for work as 9/11 doesn’t sell anymore.
There ought to be a special place in hell for Giuliani.
mickey g - August 1, 2009 | 7:30 am · Link
Rudy Giuliani didn’t “grow up” in Brooklyn. He grew up on Long Island, in the lily white towns of Garden City South and North Bellmore.
The Grand Panjandrum - August 1, 2009 | 8:42 am · Link
Glad someone debunked that BS about the UK’s crime rate. I also would like to point out, once again, that I am a strong supporter of the 2nd amendment. Each one of us has the right to protect ourselves and our families. From anyone wishing to do us harm. Period.
Cops are people. Just like the rest of us, some of them are criminals.
DBrown - August 1, 2009 | 12:14 pm · Link
@The Grand Panjandrum: You got to be kidding – cops are not like us at all. In any court their word is always taken over yours. Juries always overlook their ‘mistakes’ and refuse to convict them in most cases unless the evidence is overwhelming. In Prince Georges county in Maryland a cop executed a man in a jail cell and they dropped the investigation. Another followed a college student home into Virginia late at night (unmarked car) and as the student started to hurry to his house door, the cop jumped out of his car, yelled stop and shoot the kid in the back killing him instantly – ruling: justified because the kid, terrified by being followed by this strange person who also drove up his own drive way tried to run to his home which proved he was the guilty party and deserved to die. They can arrest you for just about any reason and if it is shown false, you still have an arrest on your record. Try cleaning that up without months of work and $$$.
Yeah, they are just like us. Some are good but too manny are a Nazi pig’s that should be in jail and not out on our streets carrying guns. Why are there no sting operations to catch these bad cops? Answer – most police would be found to be worse than some of the criminals they are suppose to protect us against.